Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

STAFF ED: Dream Act helps immigrants get an education, worth keeping

Published: Sunday, February 7, 2010

Updated: Monday, February 8, 2010 22:02

Nebraska's Dream Act has been a source of controversy since it passed in 2006.

The main sticking point: It allows students to pay in-state tuition to the University of Nebraska if they have lived in Nebraska for three years before getting a high school diploma, graduate from a Nebraska high school or live with a parent or guardian while attending high school.

Nowhere does the bill prohibit illegal immigrants from paying in-state tuition if they fulfill one of these requirements.

Now, a bill is making its way through the Nebraska Legislature that would forbid undocumented residents from getting in-state tuition under the Dream Act.

This bill is more about the principle of the thing than about logic.

Sure, illegal immigration is technically against the law, and many people are adamantly against it as a whole.

However, look at the facts: Only 43 undocumented students currently take advantage of the Dream Act.

Plus, in the long term, subsidizing those few students could be a benefit to Nebraska.

Think about it: A college-educated Nebraska resident will be much more beneficial to their community and to the state than a high school graduate.

Not to mention the human aspect of this – a component you can always count on conservatives to neglect.

Some of these students have lived in Nebraska their whole lives.

They are as Nebraskan as anyone who moved to this state when they were young.

Yes, they are technically illegal.

But rather than waste time pushing a bill that will only hurt the few illegal students who currently use the Dream Act, why not concentrate on working on the bigger, underlying issues with illegal immigration and the process to become a citizen?

Is our goal as a state to protect quality of life for our citizens or to find new ways to step on the little guy?

This bill would prevent those 43 students and many more future students from getting an education, working hard and becoming productive members of society.

The Dream Act really does live up to its name. Let's keep it that way.

opinion@dailynebraskan.com

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

3 comments

j. martin
Tue Feb 9 2010 14:26
"Not to mention the human aspect of this – a component you can always count on conservatives to neglect."

Just look for the closest sob story - a component you can always count on liberals to find. If you want to improve the qualiy of life of your citizens (and legal aliens), a great way is to remove incentive to immigrate illegally. Basic economics makes many arguments to this point.

Troy Wiegand
Tue Feb 9 2010 11:16
"Yes, they are technically illegal."

"Is our goal as a state to protect quality of life for our citizens or to find new ways to step on the little guy?"

Am I the only one that sees the cognitive disconnect between the two previous quotes? Since when can a citizen be an illegal?

Also if an illegal alien can get in-state tuition why can't I? I've lived here for four years, own a house, pay taxes, and vote. Just recently on February 5, 2010, Jason Cruise, Assistant Director of Graduate Admissions informed me that I do not qualify for in-state tuition because my wife and I moved here so that I could attend UNL. I was also informed by him that I would never qualify for in-state tuition. If my parents came here illegally then I would qualify, but since I actually obey the laws and pay my taxes I am discriminated against.

“The Dream Act really does live up to its name. Let’s keep it that way.”

By all means, let’s keep discriminating against the law abiding by giving hand-outs to the law breaking.

Matt
Tue Feb 9 2010 02:13
wow, 43 students currently getting in state tuition, not that many until you consider that many illegals pay zero taxes on their income, so really that's 43 students getting all of the benefits that families who have paid taxes the whole time they've lived in Nebraska have paid. I will support the dream act if guaranteed two things: The families total income is monitored for the entire time, including all financial transfers in and out of the USA, and second that they receive no additional financial aid that could be dispersed to other law abiding students.






log out