Secular humanists stage anti-prayer charity protest

By Ellen Hirst

Published: Monday, April 27, 2009

Updated: Tuesday, April 28, 2009

Instead of praying on the National Day of Prayer, the Lincoln Secular Humanists and the Secular Humanists of the University of Nebraska-Lincoln will eat spaghetti. 

Their protest to prayer is to respond with reason – The National Day of Reason.

The dinner will be at 5 p.m. May 7 inside the Nebraska Union. Spaghetti has symbolic correlation to UNL humanists president Thomas Zimmer's involvement with the Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster.

The noodle feed will raise money for the American Civil Liberties Union, a group dedicated to protecting citizen rights.

"The main issue of the National Day of Prayer is that it's government sponsored," Zimmer said. "Particularly when the government and religion mesh, we get aggravated."

The Lincoln Secular Humanists group is aimed at informing the public about the importance of a secular society and encouraging scientific reasoning and research.

"Basically what we try to do is educate people about secular humanism and promote it," said group coordinator for the Lincoln Secular Humanists, Brian Ellis. "Our mission is the separation between government and religion.

Both Ellis and Zimmer believe the National Day of Prayer should not be a national holiday, because not everyone is religious. According to the 2008 American Religious Identification Survey, 15 percent of Americans don't identify with any religion.

The non-religious members of these groups protest any relationship between the government and religion. They view prayer as ineffectual.

"It's hard to offer an alternative to prayer when you find it completely ineffectual," Zimmer said. "One might say that sitting on a couch is more effective."

But the mission of these secular humanist groups is far from plopping down on a couch.

"The reason we set up some sort of charitable or humanist work is because we really do view prayer as very ineffectual," Ellis said. "We need to actually roll up our sleeves and take some action. … Religion may encourage inaction. Instead of actually going out to do something, people just pray for things to get better."

Zimmer said he hopes the National Day of Reason will someday replace the National Day of Prayer, earning actual, national status.

"I live under the hope that it will happen eventually."

ELLENHIRST@DAILYNEBRASKAN.COM

Comments

8 comments
Jerry
Sat Feb 6 2010 01:20
Wow, accoding to "Your Name", atheists dont' even really have a right to raise money since they are in the minority. I guess atheists are to be at best tolerated and to be silent, like children.
Your name
Thu Nov 12 2009 10:40
when did america become the place where we cater to the minority. I thought the opitome of reason was "the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few?" Ignore the detail that its a movie quote, but even there is was spoken by the most reasonable and logical character. Suddenly America's new motto is "the squeakiest wheel gets the grease" and whichever small group of activists can make the most noise gets what they want from the government. according to this article, 15% of americans dont identify with any religion. The author didnt specify that of the 15%, only 1.6% claim agnostic or atheist. The other 13.4% just checked the "no religion" box on the survey. This doesnt verify any pro or anti God beliefs. Neither does is mean that they arent spiritual on their own, and only renounce group religious practices. According to the US Dempgraphics surveys, 76% of americans associate with christian religions(catholic, baptist, mainline and generic christian, and pentecostal), and 3.5% of americans associate with "other" religious groups(jewish, muslim, buddhist, and new religious movements). Thats 79.5% of Americans that believe in a higher being or divinity in some form. Its National Day of Prayer, not National Day of Pray the Catholic Rosary or Else. Pray to whichever god you choose, and if you dont believe in a higher or divine being......dont pray. Go about your day as if it where any other day. With as much as these secular groups cry about being offended and what not because of mild showings of faith in the public forum, I'm surprised there isnt a greater outcry from the vast majority of americans who do have some faith in one form or another. You want everything to be free and let people choose, but your not allowing people to CHOOSE religion.
in 1802 Thomas Jefferson wrote a letter to the Danbury Baptists on the topic of seperation of church and state. He states that the government should have no part in religious organizations, however he doesnt intend for the government to be totally wiped clean of all traces of faith. The original notion of seperating church and faith were to establish an unbiased governing body over the people without sway from one religious group or another. So people could practice whatever faith they chose. The fouding fathers didnt want a "national religion" that everyone was required to participate in. I'm sure they would be appalled to find the degree to which we have taken this concept and twisted it to mean something entirely different.... i could go on and on about this topic so im just going to stop here.
Jesus Christ
Wed Apr 29 2009 14:23
connection with the divine make me feel tingly inside. I know prayer is effective because I feel good. Measure my connection.
LA
Wed Apr 29 2009 11:57
If your idea of prayer is to depict God as Santa Claus, then the premise is correct that prayer is ineffective. However, as a theologian I vew prayer as a connection with the divine which does not eliminate our responsibility to act in love for the betterment of the world. I know I am not alone since many of our universities and hospitals were initiated by people living out a religious faith. Many take care of the poor and the oppressed in the world. Does this mean that all religious people are good? No. But neither are all secular humanists.
Frank Pravda
Wed Apr 29 2009 06:14
Traveling across Ohio one day I could hear on the radio the epitomy of religious thinking - money isn't everything - god is. Interrupted occasionally with the statement that this ministry will not be able to continue broadcasting without your money so send it to us at ..... . If the national day of prayer is so great how come it isn't used to get rid of the national debt and the debt of all those multimillion dollar "suffering" churches?
NE Atheist
Wed Apr 29 2009 02:18
Please provide empirical evidence that prayer accomplishes anything and I will join you in your day of prayer.
JC
Tue Apr 28 2009 21:31
Tisk TisK, what a wast of time and energy. I very much believe in science and archeology. Nether has ever disproved one item of truth as stated in God's Word, the Bible. Quite the contrary. Science and archeology is beautiful.

Oh, the suggestion that prayer is a non-action effort is so inept.

NE Atheist
Tue Apr 28 2009 17:19
3 cheers for the local humanists, agnostics and atheists!
View full site